The Journey of Mental Health and Mental Illness as a College Athlete 

By Michael Smeraldo

Fall 2023

I’ve been a student athlete since I was in high school, but when I got to college it became a whole new level of intensity. The lifestyle of a student-athlete, as many of you may know, consists of balancing many tasks. It requires a lot of dedication in many aspects, but the main ones are in the world of academics and athletics commitments. A typical day for a student-athlete consists of endless academic responsibilities along with demanding training sessions. However, athletes are not only expected to balance their academics and athletics, but they must also prioritize proper diet, work, rest, and personal time for friends and family. 

It's important to be ready when it comes to managing time efficiently to comfortably engage in both academic and athletic activities. Days consist of training like, strength and conditioning workouts, repetition drills on the playing field, team practices. The competitive season within the athlete’s sport results in intensified routines, with student athletes dedicating themselves to games, matches, or meets that may require travel and additional time commitments sometimes results in less time available to study or even just missed classes. Recovery is extremely vital, athletes rely on rest, nutrition, and physical therapy to obtain peak performance.  

Behind this demanding lifestyle, the importance of mental health in athletic performance cannot be overstated. The pressures of academic responsibilities, intense training, and the competitive nature of sports can take a toll on the mental well-being of student-athletes. Universities and colleges recognize the significance of mental health in the student-athletes and have implemented support systems. These may include access to mental health professionals, counseling services, and programs focused on stress management and even just faculty or coaches that are around the students. A sound mental state of course supports the idea of an ideal life, but it enhances performance in the field and contributes to academic success. We are going to be looking at balancing school and sport life, coping with performance pressure, self-care and mental health betterment, seeking professional help, and personal stories and experiences from student athletes and professionals.  

Balancing School and Sport Life as a College Athlete 

Balancing academic and athletic commitments is a hefty task that requires planning, discipline, and an awareness of how to prioritize. When you’re an athlete, it works very well when you set goals and try to give yourself some sort of levels that you must pass. Being reasonable in setting a goal means you must be aware of the time constraints that occur because of having intense training schedules, competitions, and travel.  

Executing a time management schedule is an essential piece in accomplishing the ways of academic and athletic commitments. This consists of intense planning, making way for specific time for classes, study hours, practices, and events for the team in general including games. Within one of the interviews that I have conducted with Cole Elmore, in which he is a coach at Wichita State golf coach in Kansas says “a lot of coaches say that 8 hours a day can be training, 6-8 can be academics and the last 6-8 could be sleeping or anything else that needs to be accomplished” (mind you this is just during the competitive season with days off included). Now that can be for a more serious athlete that may not have a job during the competitive season. Some can cut those hours in half and give themself 6-8 hours to work or just enjoy their life outside of their sport and work/school life.  An organized set of tasks dedicated to certain times of the day not only influences meeting academic deadlines, but also ensures consistent preparation for athletic endeavors.  

Prioritizing tasks is a needed skill for student athletes looking to contain a balance between academia and athletics. It can look like trying to decide whether you want to attend a super important class session or go to a meeting that your coach had set up for the team that was important to attend. Sometimes it can look like deciding between taking an exam or going to a big game to advance to a championship. According to Success Starts Within  where Eli Straw who's a sport psychology consultant and mental game coach puts a big emphasis on “negative impact on poorly managed time as a student athlete”. He says that it results in “increased anxiety, lower classroom performance, lower performance on the field/court, and depression.” 

There are ways to get through this battle, though, and there are resources within the school that allow for things to get done in a comfortable manner. According to Eli Straw where he wrote for Success Starts Within, he gave a list of tips to get started: 

  1. Identify your top priorities

  2. Plan on a weekly basis 

  3. Use a daily schedule

  4. Be flexible 

Using the tools on our smartphones or even paper such as planners, calendars, or apps can help keep a consistent, structured overview of both academic and athletic practices. According to Swimming World Magazine   where Kelsey Mitchell wrote about time management tips for student athletes, she says it's a good idea to “finish assignments in chronological order, use a planner or calendar, and avoid procrastination”. Going through a thorough process of planning and having an organizational timetable for your daily routine will allow for a much more stress free and strong based adventure through your schooling. Especially if you must focus on multiple things like social life, academics, athletics, work, and more, it is ideal to have some sort of plan that you can visually reference. 

Coping with Performance Pressure as a College Athlete 

Dealing with something like performance pressure is something that a college athlete is going to be doing a lot, whether it is with academics or athletics. To get through this pressure comfortably and successfully, athletes often turn to a combination of mindfulness techniques, visualization, and mental preparation, along with the cultivation of a positive mindset. In an article in Applied Sport Psych  where Dr. Jennifer Cumming at the University of Birmingham researched sport imagery training, she said, “Top athletes use imagery extensively to build on their strengths and help eliminate their weaknesses. To compete more effectively, imagery not only helps athletes to regulate the anxiety they experience during competitions, but also helps athletes to stay confident, focused and mentally tough”. Your mind is much more powerful than you think and using it to the fullest can be overlooked sometimes. Visualizing what you want to happen in terms of mental preparation is a crucial component of a college athlete's arsenal for handling performance pressure. 

In my Interview with Dr. Krystina Sarff, who is a sport management professor at North Central College, she told me that one of her best ways to deal with it was “I would have the same mindset all week and it really would not change for the game”.  

It's important for athletes to visualize successful performances, imagining themselves executing skills flawlessly and achieving their goals. This mental rehearsal not only promotes confidence but also helps reduce anxiety by giving the mind a look into what a  positive outcome looks like.  

Executing pre-competition routines and mental rehearsals results in a sense of familiarity for the brain. According to my interviewee Ryan who was a college athlete at Western Michigan before he graduated in spring 2023. He would always have the pregame butterflies before he stepped on the ice for his hockey game. In his junior year he started to “play what I believe is going to happen in the game, in my head for the whole two hours before the game”. He claimed that this would give him a boat load more of confidence when he stepped on the ice, which also then contributed to a calmer and more focused mindset when the pressure is on. 

Adopting a positive mindset is a fundamental aspect of coping with performance pressure. According to Spooner  where their team talks about how yoga and meditation can benefit an athlete's mind and body, they said “key components of training off the court are meditation and breathing, whether through yoga or practiced on their own. The importance of breathing techniques is sometimes overlooked by athletes.” These techniques have endless benefits in the short and long run for college athletes.  A positive mindset involves setting reasonable expectations and focusing on the process rather than solely on outcomes, so if you do something the way you wanted to, but the result wasn’t how you wanted it to be, do not react. By breaking down large goals into smaller, manageable steps, athletes can alleviate the perceived magnitude of the challenges they face. For example, in my experience playing college golf, my coach had me come up with a routine and a process for my golf game. I did not just search for results. So, I couldn’t get mad at myself for the result because the result is not as controllable as being able to control the process and how you access the task. I would have a routine for each shot, I would have 5 steps that I would follow and if I checked each step there was nothing else, I could do or control. So really, homing in on ways to make your journey achievable is HUGE.  

Self-care and Mental Health betterment for the College Athlete 

Self-care and mental health status are a huge part of the way college athletes' ventures turn out in terms of results with academics or sport. The intense demands of academics and athletics can wear you out both physically and mentally. To get through these challenges in an accomplished fashion, it is important for athletes to prioritize getting adequate rest, maintaining proper nutrition, and incorporating relaxation techniques into their routines. A former student athlete gave some tips for mental health and wellbeing at NCAA

  • Visualization 

  • Positive self-talk  

  • Relaxation 

  • Preparation  

  • Balance 

Being able to incorporate these tips into your self-care will often result in a more sustainable journey through your college athletics.  

Quality sleep is not only super important for physical recovery, but cognitive function, and emotional wellbeing. As reported by International Universities Strength and Conditioning Association, “Studies show that sleep deprivation can increase reaction times more than 300%. Fatigue due to insufficient sleep impairs reaction times in a similar manner to drinking alcohol.” Lack of sleep results in an almost 20% rise in the perceived difficulty of moderate to high-intensity exercise. Considering that extending sleep improves daytime alertness, vigilance, and mood, it becomes evident that sufficient sleep can improve the capacity to endure intense training sessions. Prioritizing consistent sleep patterns and engaging in sufficient hours of rest influence enhanced physical performance, improved focus, and better mood regulation. 

Proper diet or nutrition is not only crucial for external health but also plays a significant role in supporting our internal mental wellbeing. Explained by Access Sports Med  athletes should incorporate the following practices into their routine: avoid skipping meals, establish a consistent eating schedule, prioritize hydration, and make wise choices when snacking.Top of Form 

Enjoying relaxation techniques is another crucial aspect of self-care for college athletes. The pressures of academic expectations and athletic performance can lead to heightened stress levels and athletes often find solace in practices such as meditation, deep breathing exercises, and deep relaxation. As stated in uchealth, “Rest and recovery is an equally essential component of an exercise program because it gives the body time to repair, rebuild, and strengthen itself between workouts”. Finding time in your schedule to rest is super important and it cannot be overlooked.  

The intense demands of academics and athletics can wear you out both physically and mentally. To get through these challenges, prioritize getting adequate rest, maintaining proper nutrition, and incorporating relaxation techniques into their routines.

Ways to get help as a Struggling College Athlete  

Engaging in getting professional help for mental health cannot be overlooked and feeds to the idea of an overall wellbeing for college athletes. As mentioned in Medicat  Students have resources that include confidential support to student athletes struggling with various mental health issues. Regardless of whatever stigma surrounds mental health issues, knocking down these walls and becoming aware of when to seek help are key elements to a college athlete's journey.   

Breaking the stereotype that people have in terms of the perception of getting help with mental health can and has been annihilated by the act of people having conversations and being open to the idea of the act. The athletic community, coaching community, and faculty can feed in to creating a helpful and good vibe to where seeking help is viewed as a strength rather than a weakness. It is unfortunate but according to digital research .bsu it says that research conducted in 2021 by the British Journal of Sports Medicine revealed that approximately 25% of college athletes exhibit symptoms of depression. It is noteworthy that 33% of college athletes eventually discontinue their involvement in their respective sports, which aligns with these findings. Bringing this subject to normal by using discussion helps get rid of the stigma that comes with the act, it will result in people being more comfortable with it and more college athletes getting help. 

In a recent interview with Dr. Krystina Sarff, out of North Central College, valuable insights were shared on navigating the mental health challenges that come with being a college athlete. Dr. Sarff emphasized the importance of time management and provided tips to help students succeed both academically and athletically. One crucial piece of advice from Dr. Sarff was to avoid procrastination. She stressed the significance of maintaining a consistent eating routine, including breakfast and dinner. Hydration throughout the day, coupled with activities such as meditation or yoga, was recommended to manage stress effectively. Having a well-structured schedule was highlighted as a key element in balancing the demands of academics and sports. Furthermore, Dr. Sarff suggested choosing a major that aligns with the commitments of being a student-athlete. Despite dedicating substantial time to her sport, she found positive influence and motivation in the presence of her teammates. 

I also interviewed Coach Cole Elmore from Wichita State University in Kansas. Coach Elmore emphasized the importance of maintaining a healthy lifestyle by eating well and following a consistent sleep schedule. Effective communication with coaches, staying informed about sports and academics, and planning were identified as key elements in achieving success both on and off the field. Coach Elmore shared a personal story of overcoming challenges as a dual-sport athlete, showcasing the resilience required to balance demanding training schedules and academic responsibilities. His dedication and positive mindset proved instrumental in achieving success in both sport and academics. 

Another insightful interview was conducted with a student athlete by the name of Ryan Peters, a recent graduate from Western Michigan with a degree in Finance and a notable hockey player for the school. Embracing flexibility, setting weekly and monthly goals, planning for post-graduation, and becoming proficient in multitasking were among the strategies Ryan recommended. Sharing a personal experience, Ryan recounted a challenging decision he faced between a crucial hockey game and a midterm exam. His ability to prioritize effectively allowed him to excel in both areas, demonstrating the importance of careful planning and resilience. 

There are many ways to get help with your mental health as a student athlete and it is important to be aware of all your outlets that you have in terms of bettering your mental health. There are outlets all around you, do not be afraid to use them, people are more willing to listen and help than you think.  

Call to Action

Join in the mission to prioritize mental health in athletic success! At The Complete Athlete Foundation, they are dedicated to raising awareness and providing essential mental health resources tailored to athletes, coaches, and parents. Together, we can conquer the attainment of bettering the well-being in athletes and ensure that mental health is a fundamental aspect of their journey to success. Embrace the vision of the Complete Athlete Foundation and be a part of the movement towards whole body health in the world of sports! 

Michael grew up in the suburbs of Chicago playing baseball, hockey, and golf from a young age. He goes to North Central College in downtown Naperville, Illinois, where he played golf for one year after transferring from Moraine Valley where he played one year of golf as well. He is going to be graduating with a Major in Marketing and a minor in Organizational Communications in May 2024 at North Central College. Michael wants to have a beautiful family one day and live on a spectacular farmland with animals. After experiencing work in many different industries, he is willing to work in whatever industry gives him a calling once his academic journeys are over.